Book Review: Hallowe'en Party

Hallowe'en Party by Agatha Christie
Pocket Books, 1986 (originally published 1969); 255 pages

Thirteen-year-old Joyce Reynolds is found drowned in the apple-bobbing tub at a Halloween party after she claims to have witnessed a murder when she was younger. Because Joyce was known to exaggerate events to make herself seem more important and because mystery novelist Ariadne Oliver attended the party and Joyce wanted to impress the famous writer. While most people assume that Joyce was killed by a sociopathic tramp, Ariadne believes that she might have been murdered because of her claim to have witnessed a murder. Ariadne takes her theory to Hercule Poirot, who takes the case.

Hallowe'en Party is one of Christie's later novels, which I don't consider to be nearly as good as her work from the 1920s, '30s, and '40s. The plot meanders through so many irrelevant details, seemingly not in an effort to create red herrings, but for no good reason whatsoever. Christie also seems to use the novel as a vehicle for discussion of the British justice system in the mid-twentieth century, as many of the characters either lament the lack of justice since hanging was done away with or try to explain all criminals as being merely misunderstood and coming from a bad childhood.

In terms of the conclusion, parts of the "big reveal" for which Poirot is so famous don't make any sense with the rest of the story--there is not one bit of evidence concerning the actions of two characters in relation to a subplot, yet somehow Poirot guessed correctly.

On the whole, Hallowe'en Party is unsatisfying as a mystery, and doesn't even have enough of Christie's creative spark to carry the illogical plot or the annoying M. Poirot. The only highlight is Christie's excellent descriptive passages of characters and settings.

Rating: 3.8

Top Ten Tuesday: Most Anticipated Books for 2013

Hosted by The Broke and the Bookish

I have exactly three books on this list, and one of them may be wishful thinking. There are few living authors whose work I admire enough to keep track of publication dates, and the dead authors I admire don't have new publications (unfortunately). Also, my efforts to become better educated mean I'm reading less modern fluff. So here's my very short list for 2013:

1. Song of the Quarkbeast by Jasper Fforde (US release): This is the second book in the Chronicles of Kazam series, following The Last Dragonslayer, and although it's already out in UK, I'm looking forward to the US release so I can get it from the library.

2. The next book in the Mary Russell series by Laurie R. King: I have absolutely no proof that another MR book will be published next year, but considering that there's been one book per year 2009-2012, I'm hopeful.

3. Speaking from Among the Bones by Alan Bradley: This is the fifth book in the Flavia de Luce series, which chronicles the exploits of the eponymous 10-year-old chemist and detective. I won an advance copy through the LibraryThing Early Reviewers program, so I'm reading this 2013 release in 2012.

Book Review: The Peterkin Papers

The Peterkin Papers by Lucretia P. Hale
Houghton, Mifflin and Company, 1893 (originally published 1880); 120 pages

Note: The Peterkin Papers is available free for Kindle.  You don't need a Kindle to read it; just check out Amazon's Kindle Cloud Reader at read.amazon.com.  (You will need an Amazon account.)

The Peterkins are a rather unusual family living somewhere in New England (Massachusetts, I think, as Boston is mentioned with some regularity).  The family consists of Mr. and Mrs. Peterkin and their children, Agamemnon, Elizabeth Eliza, Solomon John, and the three little boys (with their ubiquitous India-rubber boots).  The family is always having humorous adventures and problems while trying to accomplish simple tasks of daily living.

I enjoyed The Peterkin Papers very much, although I didn't find them as laugh-out-loud funny now as I did when I read them in elementary school.  The book, which is a collection of short stories, is intended for children, and although it's over 100 years old, I think today's children will still see the humor in the situations in which the Peterkins find themselves.  The book also provides a window into how people lived in the late 1800s.  My only criticism is that as an adult, I realize that as silly as the Peterkins are, it's a wonder they manage to stay alive.

As part of my volunteer work at a local research library, I work with newspapers from the late twentieth century.  In a paper from 1978, I found an article describing three-legged pantyhose, with a picture similar to this:

The idea is that when you get a run in one leg, you can put on the spare leg, thus making your pantyhose last longer.  My only question is, what do you do with the spare leg before you need it?

Book Review: Perelandra

Perelandra by C. S. Lewis

Simon & Schuster, 1996 (originally published 1943); 222 pages

In the second book of C. S. Lewis' space trilogy, Ransom continues his adventures, traveling this time to Perelandra (Venus) to prevent the Venusian Eve from falling into sin.  Weston appears on the scene, possessed by the Devil, to tempt the Lady.

I generally don't like Christian science fiction or fantasy that creates a world where God has a different name--it strikes me as irreverent at best and blasphemous at worst, and more than a little idolatrous.  But Perelandra works for me, because Lewis uses our real universe and our real God instead of creating a sorry shadow of God.  He also doesn't encounter the problem of having to create "another Jesus" to bring salvation to his fictional world, because the Lady of Perelandra withstands temptation.

I'm not sure that Lewis' vision of life on Earth had Adam and Eve not sinned is particularly accurate, but as Lewis himself said in another of his works, "No one is allowed to know what would have happened."  So really, his guess is as good as mine.  Besides, it's not as if Genesis is overly descriptive of life before the Fall. I suppose it is a kindness, really, that God didn't describe in great detail everything we as a race gave up so that we could pursue the illusion of freedom, a freedom that makes us slaves.

Otherwise, I found a lot to love in Perelandra.  It's a very theological book, and I revel in theology, so it just works for me.  Although a lot of the book focuses on temptation and sin, I loved the subtext of the revelous joy that comes from serving God, no matter how great or small the task He lays before us.

Rating: 4.9/5.0

Top Ten Tuesday: Books/Authors for which I'm Thankful

Several of the book bloggers I follow (not all of whom are listed on the sidebar--I need to update that at some point) participate in Top Ten Tuesday hosted by The Broke and the Bookish.  It looked like a lot of fun, so I just had to join in.

To be honest, I'm thankful for all the books I've ever read, ever will read, ever will want to read, ever published, and all the authors and editors and publishers and translators who work so hard to make the books.  But that's rather more than ten, so here's the short list:

1. The Bible: I'm thankful that God inspired people to write stuff down for us rather than leaving us to our own doomed devices.

2. C. S. Lewis: Let's see, he wrote the Chronicles of Narnia, the Space Trilogy, the Four Loves, more essays than I can count.  Essentially, the man was brilliant.

3. Jasper Fforde: I think Fforde is the only author about whom I can say "I've read everything he's ever had published."  Or at least I can say that until his next book comes out, which I will request from my library three to six months early so I can get one of the first copies.  Seriously, Jasper Fforde is funny, witty, genius, and totally worth reading if you like absurdist sci-fi/fantasy alternate history meta-fiction.

4. I Capture the Castle: Written by Dodie Smith of 101 Dalmatians fame, this is one of my absolute favorite books

5. The Lord of the Rings: I first read LotR in fifth grade, and I've been rather obsessed ever since.

6. Arthur Conan Doyle: I read TONS of mysteries as a kid (Nancy Drew, Hardy Boys, Boxcar Children, Encyclopedia Brown), but I credit Sherlock Holmes with my life-long mystery novel and TV crime show obsession.

7. Connie Willis: Four words: Time-travelling Oxford historians.

8. M. F. K. Fisher: Brilliant American food writer who spent much of her life in France.  This quote from one of her essays more or less defines my theory of hospitality and cooking:

... but I still think that one of the pleasantest of all emotions is to know that I, I with brain and my hands, have nourished my beloved few, that I have concocted a stew or a story, a rarity or plain dish, to sustain them truly against the hungers of the world.

9. Julian of Norwich: "All shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner of things shall be well"

10. Dorothy L. Sayers: I love Lord Peter and that's all there is to it.  (It does help that he's wealthy and has excellent taste in books.)

Book Review: The Richest Woman in America

The Richest Woman in America: Hetty Green in the Gilded Age by Janet Wallach

Doubleday, 2012 (bound galley); 276 pages

Note: I received this book as part of LibraryThing's Early Reviewer program.

Before picking up this book, I had never heard of Hetty Green, who inherited and invested her way to an estate that at the time of her death in 1916, was worth over $2 billion in today's money.  She did this at a time when women were not supposed to be involved in business and certainly not in Wall Street.  Green's favored strategy was buy low, sell high, and she also made her money go farther by living a plain and frugal life at a time when people with comparable wealth were living extravagantly.

Throughout the book, Wallach uses an odd mix of formal and conversational language, as if she couldn't decide whether her audience should be academic or popular.  She goes into great detail on trivial aspects of Green's life, while glossing over major events.  In areas where there is little information on Green's life, Wallach brings in anecdotes of the period, but does not connect these anecdotes to Green in a clear or meaningful way.  Her writing style is extremely passive.  There are a few typographical errors, but since I received a bound galley rather than a final copy of the book, I hope these have been corrected in the final version.  A major flaw is that black people are nearly always referred to as "colored" or "Negro," even in passages written by Wallach that are not quotes from the period.  Even though these were common and accepted terms in the nineteenth century, they should not be used for what appears to be no good reason in a modern work.

Rating: 3.3/5.0